|
Endorsing more good approaches: Luminus-Nichia... and more on 5mm LEDs for lighting applications
Author: Tom Griffiths - Publisher
March 26, 2009... While there was the expected amount of coverage on recent announcements regarding
a relationship between Luminus and Nichia, we would offer an additional thought...
the Luminus-Nichia deal will have a revolutionary impact on the LED marketplace
and solid state lighting industry. (Oh, is that all?). You will find more on that topic further
below, but first, some unfinished business regarding the suitability of 5mm
packaged LEDs for general lighting applications. In our most
recent guest editorial, Bob Sagebiel commented on the 5mm packages that
seem to be too prevalent at the consumer level right now (saw some more at Sam's
Club last week... "Lights of America" was the brand, and it was made
in China... hmmm). He contended that they don't work well to start out, that
they then proceed to discolor, die prematurely and generally reflect badly on
the solid state lighting industry. In response, he received plenty of notes
of praise for driving that stake into the heart of those devious little devices.
And we received one note that suggested we were wrong in our broad-reaching
conclusion. Now who would offer that opinion? One of those fly-by-night "LED
lightbulb" producers offering their "cluster bombs" to unsuspecting
"green" consumers?
Well, the opinion was provided by none other than the distinguished Dr. Daniel
Doxsee, General Manager, Nichia America (his title now better reflecting the responsibilities he's had for many years as "senior sales manager" in the lower key Japanese system of titles). It turns
out that recognizing that there were plenty of non-capable 3mm and 5mm packaged
devices out there, Nichia set out a while ago to build lighting-capable versions,
and succeeded with their DS series. I had missed this, Bob had missed this,
and it looks like a good chunk of the industry missed this. Since mid-2007 Nichia
has offered a line of 3mm and 5mm packaged white and color LEDs that incorporate
proprietary resin and other design features that get the heat out, stand up
to the heat that's left, and last 40,000 hours at rated drive currents (or
longer if you drive them more gently). Oh my. Soooo.... once again, we can't
judge the book by its cover so to speak. Just as all LED luminaires or conventional
power-LEDs are not created equal, neither are those proliferate dome-shaped
small packaged chips. An illustratory slide is here,
a lifetime curve is here
and the specs for the product families are here
and here (the
first two PDFs may spur your Acrobat reader to install Japanese fonts... it's
quick and easy). If a luminaire you're considering has 3mm or 5mm chips in it,
approach with caution, but don't rule it out. If they selected Nichia devices,
the manufacturer should be happy to share reassuring data with you.
Now back to the Luminus-Nichia story... It's actually not a very complicated
story, but it may be one of the bigger developments in the LED and solid state
lighting industries we'll see for this year. We already know that Nichia is
one of the LED companies that knows what it's doing, most notably with its strong
reputation for very consistent and efficient white LEDs. If you've followed
the news here, or on LIGHTimes, our more
supply-chain oriented news site, you will have seen news and commentary on Luminus
Devices, mostly regarding their Phlatlight large photonic lattice vertical LEDs
being applied as the light engines in DLP projection TVs, and most recently
in the new generation of "pocket projectors". Up until recently, their
story hasn't been about efficiency as much as it has been about putting out
more, better or longer lasting light on the same or lower energy budget. Besides
the better color and seemingly infinite lifetime of the projection TV product,
they found other niches such as medical applications, where there was a benefit
to great color rendering without heat in the beam (think "colonoscopy"
and you can imagine the benefit).
On Feb. 2 Luminus and Nichia announced they had entered a cross licensing and
manufacturing partnership (ref. coverage),
as well as marketing agreements that taken all together, appear to define a
very comprehensive relationship. What we would expect to see resulting from
that would be some new products for both companies that reflect the obvious synergies.
As Udi Meirav, Luminus CEO, commented to us, "Nichia is a fully accomplished
partner that is good at every part of the LED equation. This partnership opens
new ground as it enables both companies to pursue high-efficiency white LED
applications with large monolithic chips." We didn't need to wait long
to see an example of this synergy. On Feb. 17, Luminus announced its SST-90
packaged white LED (ref coverage),
which delivers 1000 lumens while consuming only 10 watts at its nominal drive
current. 100 lm/watt for a cool white LED is state-of-the-art from a handful
of high quality LED producers. 1000 lumens from a single chip, while being
driven at nominal levels, is new ground. And if the application calls for
more brightness at the expense of some efficiency, a single SST-90 can deliver
up to 2250 lumens at its maximum rated drive current. That's a unique capability
that comes from a truly large chip (and at 9 square-millimeters, it really is
large) that has lots of surface area from which to dissipate that normally component-killing
heat.
A big, bright, reliable packaged LED opens up some very interesting applications
spaces, most notably the high-bay lighting which is currently served by HID
lamps putting out 20,000 lumens. Throwing 200 100-lumen LEDs at the application
creates a significant packaging, price and engineering challenge. Throwing 10-20
of this kind of large chip at it creates a substantially more viable product
scenario. Will the big chip solution be reliable? Based on Luminus' experience
in the projection TV environment, the answer is yes. In those arenas, the original
Luminus designs have been running for 2+ years at something around 2.5A/sq-mm
with no LED failures. (2.5A/sq-mm is a bit over twice the nominal drive current
of this new chip, and there is a very direct relationship in LEDs that extends
the lifetime the more gently you drive them). While we haven't heard any announcements
regarding new products from Nichia yet, keep an eye out later this year for
the first new products based on the large chip platforms. The "tens-of-kilo-lumen"
applications are now available!
Source/Type:
Solid State Lighting Design LED Lighting News - Editorials
See the Current Industry News Summary
See this article in its orginal context, with the other current news from the same week
|